This Decision Tree can help you decide whether to repair or replace your commercial HVAC unit.
Repair a commercial HVAC system if the unit is within its expected service life (ie, less than 15 years old for a typical RTU) and the cost to repair (less than 50% of a replacement unit) will resolve a single component failure. Replace a failed RTU when a single repair approaches or exceeds 50% of the cost of a replacement unit or when frequent failures indicate that end of life has been reached.
In addition to the rule of thumb above for whether to repair or replace a rooftop unit (RTU), there are 6 additional factors that need to be considered when making the decision for repair or replacement of a rooftop unit, such as the impact of refrigerant rules, energy targets and tenant downtimes in order to make an informed commercial decision.
1. How Old Is the Unit?
“ASHRAE considers 15 years to be the average life of a single-zone and multi-zone packaged RTU. Lennox Commercial says that packaged RTUs typically have a 15-20 year life depending on a number of factors including how long it is run, where it is used and how well it is maintained. Note that as a unit gets past 12 years of age, there are fewer parts available and the unit becomes less efficient.”
2. Apply the 50% Rule
Compare the cost of repair to replace the unit. Typically this rule is tightened as the unit gets older. This is because each dollar spent repairing an older unit to maintain operation will get less years of service from the unit than the same dollar spent on a newer unit with only one part failure.
3. Read the Repair History
Don’t judge a unit by one repair bill. Look at the 12-month history of repairs for the same unit and add up the total of all the repair costs. Then add the cost of the proposed repair to that number to get the real cost of repair (versus replacement).
4. Check the Refrigerant
Consider the type of refrigerant that your RTU is using. Are they using R-410A or older R-22 systems? R-410A systems can be serviced but leaks in Refrigerants with High Global Warming Potential (GWP) such as R-410A become very expensive to repair. Systems with 50 lbs or more of refrigerant in them are covered under the state of Washington’s Refrigerant Management Program. Systems with chronic leaks are obvious candidates for replacement.
5. Count Energy and Compliance Costs
An older RTU may actually cost more to run each year than parts for the repairs over the same time period. Be sure to factor the energy and the impact to your Clean Buildings compliance plans into your consideration as well. For example, RTUs serving Tier 1 buildings of 90,001-220,000 sq ft of floor area must come into compliance by June 1, 2027 and Tier 2 buildings by July 1, 2027.
6. Plan Around Downtime
An emergency change-out to deal with an unexpected failure can sometimes end up being costlier than a planned replacement, not to mention the possible inconvenience to the tenants. Planning ahead to replace older RTUs on an off-season can save a lot of headaches in the long run. On the Morrison Hotel project in downtown Seattle for example, Morgan Mechanical replaced the older RTUs on weekends under street-use permits to keep the building running while work was done.
FAQ
How long will a commercial rooftop unit last?
The ASHRAE median for the life of a commercial rooftop unit is 15 years or so. Some units will last longer, others will wear out sooner if not properly serviced and maintained.
In the short term, yes! But in the long term, no! It will eventually reach a point where all repairs will cease to be cost-effective once the cost of repair parts and labor exceed half the cost of a new unit. Additionally, many repairs can cause frequent breakdowns that have a negative impact on the life of the unit.
Get a Straight Repair-or-Replace Answer
If you are still unsure whether a replacement or repair would be best for your rooftop unit, Morgan Mechanical’s union technicians and Certified Energy Managers can perform an inspection of the RTU and provide you with a list of past repairs as well as a cost estimate for continued repair versus replacement for the balance of the RTU’s useful life. For now though, if it’s blowing warm air, read Why Is My Rooftop Unit Blowing Warm Air? (R1).
Call 425-582-0473 or book at hvacmorgan.com.